On this page
- What does "subject to repairs" mean on an appraisal?
- Who is responsible for repairs the appraiser flags?
- What if repairs aren't done before closing?
- Repair the water damage and ask for a reinspection
- File an insurance claim when the cause is a covered loss
- Sell the house as-is instead of repairing the water damage
- What should I send Prime Restoration first?
- How serious is a roof leak, and does it matter how long the water has been there?
What does "subject to repairs" mean on an appraisal?
An appraisal "subject to repairs" means the appraiser set a value on the house as it will be after named repairs, not as it sits today. The lender will not close, or will not release the full loan, until the repair is done and proven, or until the loan program's own fallback kicks in: an escrow holdback, a repair set-aside, or an as-is appraisal at a lower value.
A Michigan appraiser does not invent this rule. HUD, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac write it into the handbooks that every FHA, conventional, and most refinance loans follow. The appraiser applies a condition rating, and water damage pushes that rating down.
| Rating | What it means | Water-damage example |
|---|---|---|
| C4 | Adequately maintained, minor or cosmetic deferred items | Minor damage to a wall or trim from an old, fixed leak |
| C5 | Significant wear, but still sound enough for occupancy | A roof that is worn or cupped, with no active leak |
| C6 | Severe damage that affects soundness; not eligible for sale to Fannie Mae at this rating | An active roof leak, weather intrusion, or a failing foundation |
Who is responsible for repairs the appraiser flags?
The appraiser flags the condition and recommends repairs. The lender, called the mortgagee in FHA rules, decides which repairs are actually required and how the loan closes around them. "Regardless of the Appraiser's suggested repairs, the Mortgagee will determine which repairs are required," says HUD Handbook 4000.1.
On a conventional loan, Fannie Mae's rule is similar: a deficiency that affects safety, soundness or structural integrity must be repaired to at least a C5 rating before the loan sells to Fannie Mae, and a house rated C6 is not eligible for sale to Fannie Mae at all. The FHA appraiser must also limit any required repair to what keeps the property safe, keeps it marketable and protects the health of the people living in it, so a cosmetic finish is not the same fight as an active roof leak.
An appraiser also cannot write their own repair order and skip the lender. HUD Handbook 4000.1 requires the appraiser to "condition the appraisal for the required repairs," then hands that condition to the lender, who signs off on the actual scope before any contractor starts. That is why the letter you got names a condition, not a finished repair order, and why the next call is to a contractor who can turn that condition into a line-item scope the lender will accept.
This split matters for the homeowner because it means two different people have to agree before work starts: the appraiser, who names the problem, and the lender, who sets the exact repair. A scope that answers only the appraiser's note, and not the lender's actual requirement, can still fail at the reinspection stage. Sending the full letter, not a summary of it, to whoever writes your repair scope avoids that second round.
What if repairs aren't done before closing?
Three loan types each give a different fallback when the repair is not finished by closing. A conventional loan can close with a completion escrow: funds equal to 120 percent of the estimated repair cost, capped at 10 percent of the "as completed" value, held until the work is done and verified on Fannie Mae Form 1004D. An FHA loan can close with a repair escrow if the Mortgagee decides the home is still habitable and safe. A HECM reverse mortgage can close before repairs finish only if the Commissioner estimates the remaining repair cost at 15 percent or less of the maximum claim amount, with a signed agreement covering how that money gets paid out.
A HECM for Purchase is stricter: where the deficiency threatens health, safety or the soundness of the property, the seller must finish the repair before closing, and the appraiser writes the report "Subject To" that repair.
Repair the water damage and ask for a reinspection
This is the fastest path when the house has equity and the owner wants to keep the loan moving. Prime Restoration finds the water source with a moisture meter and a thermal camera, dries the structure, and does the repair under Michigan Residential Builder license #262500492: drywall, flooring, ceilings, mold that came from the leak, and the rebuild. A roof leak or a plumbing leak needs a licensed roofer or a licensed plumber to fix the roof or the pipe itself, and Prime Restoration can help get one out to the property. See lender-required repairs after an appraisal for how an FHA or conventional file sorts a required repair from an optional one.
When the repair is done, the lender orders a reinspection. The appraiser or an inspector verifies the work, often on Fannie Mae Form 1004D or the FHA Compliance Inspection Report, form HUD-92051. Dated photos, moisture readings and a written completion record from Prime Restoration are what that reinspection checks against.
Prime Restoration works this repair across Macomb and Oakland County, including Sterling Heights, Shelby Township, Macomb Township, Clinton Township, Rochester Hills, Troy, Birmingham, West Bloomfield and Royal Oak, and is on site in 25 minutes in Macomb, Oakland, Washtenaw and Huron counties. See what appraisers look for: water damage and roof leaks for the exact signs that trigger a "subject to repairs" condition before you even get the written letter.
Appraisal or loan on hold for water damage? Prime finds the source and writes the repair scope your lender asks for.
(586) 277-1069File an insurance claim when the cause is a covered loss
When the water damage came from a sudden event the policy covers, a burst pipe, a toilet overflow, a washing machine line, the homeowner files the claim with their own carrier, and Prime Restoration documents the loss and writes the scope the carrier reviews. The policy and the carrier decide what is covered. Call Prime Restoration first at (586) 277-1069, then report the loss to the carrier the same day. See Prime Restoration insurance claims help for how that documentation step works.
Michigan's insurance code sets a payment clock once a claim is filed: the carrier must tell you in writing, within 30 days of the claim, what it needs as proof of loss, and benefits not paid on time draw 12 percent simple interest a year starting 60 days after proof of loss is received. Michigan's insurance regulator also tells homeowners not to simply call the damage a flood, because other causes, like a sewer backup or a failing sump pump, may be covered under the policy when a flood is not. If a carrier has already paid less than the repair scope calls for, see underpaid insurance claim in Michigan.
Sell the house as-is instead of repairing the water damage
An owner who does not want to carry the repair, the loan delay, and a reinspection can sell the house as-is. Michigan's Seller Disclosure Act form asks a seller directly whether there has been evidence of water in the basement or crawl space, whether the roof leaks, and whether there is flooding, drainage or structural damage, and the seller must answer those items and update the buyer on any change before closing. The disclosure form itself is not a warranty and does not replace the buyer's own inspection.
See selling a house with water damage in Michigan for the disclosure steps and how an as-is sale compares with repair first.
What should I send Prime Restoration first?
- Step 1The appraisal page or the lender letterThe page that names the repair condition, or the letter that states what the lender needs, in writing or as a photo.
- Step 2The loan typeFHA, conventional, HELOC, cash-out refinance or reverse mortgage. Each one carries a different repair rule and a different fallback.
- Step 3Where the water isRoof, ceiling, basement, a specific room. Name every spot, even a small stain, since the appraiser may have flagged more than one.
- Step 4How long it has been thereA guess is fine. "Since the spring" or "noticed it at the inspection" both help Prime read the moisture reading against your timeline.
- Step 5Any insurance contact so farWhether a claim is already open, denied, or not yet filed, so the scope and the claim stay lined up.
- Step 6Your closing or reinspection date, if you have oneThe lender's own deadline tells Prime Restoration how fast the repair, the drying time and the written record need to move.
How serious is a roof leak, and does it matter how long the water has been there?
An FHA appraiser treats an active roof leak and a worn, dry roof differently, and the Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac condition ratings do the same: a roof that is "significantly worn, cupped, or curled but with no apparent active leaks" can still rate C5, while an active leak or weather intrusion with structural damage rates C6, a rating that is not eligible for sale to Fannie Mae. The length of time water sat matters for the same reason an appraiser cares about it: longer exposure means more structure got wet, which means mold risk and a wider repair scope, not just a patch.
Finding the source first, not just the stain, is why Prime Restoration starts every visit with a moisture meter and a thermal camera. A ceiling stain can come from a roof, a bathroom above it, or a pipe in the wall, and the repair scope the lender accepts has to name the actual source, not a guess.
A repair scope that names the wrong source gets rejected at reinspection, and the owner pays for a second visit and a second delay on the loan. A thermal scan reads the temperature difference between a wet wall and a dry one, which is how Prime Restoration finds a leak that is still inside a wall or above a ceiling, not just the stain it already left behind. The moisture reading then tells the crew how far the water traveled, so the scope covers the full wet area and not only the visible mark.

