On this page
- Who is responsible for FHA repairs?
- What counts as a lender-required repair under FHA?
- Can a conventional loan require repairs?
- What is the compliance inspection for a lender-required repair?
- What if repairs aren't done before closing?
- What loan programs pay for lender-required repairs?
- From the repair list to the lender's reinspection
- FHA, conventional and HECM loans: how each treats water damage
- What does Prime Restoration do for a lender-required repair?
Who is responsible for FHA repairs?
HUD Handbook 4000.1 tells the FHA appraiser to check three things tied to water on every house it inspects. The handbook says the roof covering must have a remaining physical life of at least two years, or the appraiser must report the deficiency and make the appraisal subject to inspection by a professional roofer. The same section says the basement must be free of dampness and wetness, and the crawl space must not have standing water or a sign of past moisture, such as a water stain or a smell of mold. When the appraiser finds one of these problems, that finding is what makes an appraisal subject to repairs.
The appraiser does not pick the repair list. HUD Handbook 4000.1 states it in one line: regardless of the appraiser's suggested repairs, the mortgagee will determine which repairs are required. The mortgagee is the lender. The lender reads the appraiser's report and sets the required repair list, and the handbook limits that list to repairs needed to keep the property safe, sound, marketable and healthy for the people living in it. Who is responsible for FHA repairs: the lender decides what is required, working from the appraiser's report, and a licensed contractor completes the work.
What counts as a lender-required repair under FHA?
HUD Handbook 4000.1 lists three water damage conditions that turn into a lender-required repair on an FHA appraisal in Michigan or any other state.
- A roof covering that lets in moisture, or has less than two years of remaining life.
- A basement with water damage: dampness, wetness or standing water.
- A crawl space with standing water, or evidence of past water damage such as a water-stained subfloor or a smell of mold.
Can a conventional loan require repairs?
Yes. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac grade a house on a condition scale from C1 to C6, and the scale names water damage directly. The joint UAD Condition and Quality Rating Definitions describe a C5 property as one with significant wear, giving "roofing that is significantly worn, cupped, or curled but with no apparent active leaks" as an example. A C6 property has damage that affects the soundness or structural integrity of the house, and the named examples include "active roof leaks," water intrusion that causes structural damage, and a damaged or failing foundation.
The Fannie Mae Selling Guide, section B4-1.3-06, is direct about what a C6 rating does to the loan: loans secured by a property with a C6 condition rating are not eligible for sale to Fannie Mae. Any deficiency that affects the safety, soundness or structural integrity of the house must be repaired to a minimum C5 rating before the loan is sold, and the appraisal must be marked subject to completion of those specific repairs. So the answer to can a conventional loan require repairs is yes, and water damage that reaches a C6 finding is one of the conditions that forces it. A Michigan homeowner selling or refinancing with water damage on the appraisal faces this same C5 and C6 rule on any conventional loan.
What is the compliance inspection for a lender-required repair?
FHA and conventional loans each use a different form to close out the repair. On an FHA loan, the mortgagee certifies on Form HUD-92051, the Compliance Inspection Report, that the incomplete construction, alterations or repairs have been completed to the standard the appraisal set. On a conventional loan, the Fannie Mae Selling Guide, section B4-1.2-05, has the appraiser complete the Completion Report section of Form 1004D, based on an on-site visual inspection, and the documentation must include a visually verifiable exhibit, meaning a photo of the finished repair.
A dated set of photos and moisture readings from the day the repair finished is the record that supports either form. That is the paperwork Prime Restoration hands the homeowner at the end of a water-damage repair.
Appraisal or loan on hold for water damage? Prime finds the source and writes the repair scope your lender asks for.
(586) 277-1069What if repairs aren't done before closing?
Each loan type has its own rule for a repair that is not finished by the closing date. On FHA loans, HUD Handbook 4000.1 lets the mortgagee set up a repair escrow when the repair cannot be done before closing, as long as the house is habitable and safe to live in at closing, and the escrow must hold enough money to cover the repair. The handbook adds that the cost of the borrower's own labor cannot go into that escrow account.
On conventional loans, the Fannie Mae Selling Guide, section B4-1.2-05, requires a completion escrow for repairs postponed past closing, funded at 120 percent of the estimated repair cost where there is no guaranteed fixed-price contract, and it caps the cost of finishing the repairs at 10 percent of the "as completed" appraised value of the house.
On a reverse mortgage, 24 CFR 206.47 lets the loan close before the repair is finished if the Commissioner estimates the remaining repair cost at 15 percent or less of the maximum claim amount, with the money held in a Repair Set Aside. A contractor is paid only after an inspection confirms the work, and the lender cannot reimburse a borrower for labor the borrower performed. A reverse mortgage used to buy a house is stricter: if the water damage threatens health, safety or the soundness of the property, the seller must complete the repair before closing, and the appraisal is marked subject to that completion.
What loan programs pay for lender-required repairs?
Two FHA programs roll the repair cost into the loan itself. The Standard 203(k) mortgage covers remodeling and repairs with a minimum repair cost of $5,000, and it requires a 203(k) consultant. The Limited 203(k) is for minor remodeling and non-structural repairs only, does not require a consultant, and has no minimum repair cost; HUD sets a maximum for the Limited 203(k) in the handbook, and that cap has reportedly moved since the handbook text was last checked, so confirm the current figure with a 203(k) lender before you plan around a number.
Fannie Mae's HomeStyle Renovation and Freddie Mac's CHOICERenovation loans let a conventional borrower finance renovation work, including a water-damage repair, inside the purchase or refinance loan. Ask your loan officer which program fits your loan type and your repair cost before you choose one.
VA loans have their own property requirements, separate from FHA, conventional and HECM rules. Ask your loan officer how a VA appraisal treats water damage on your file.
From the repair list to the lender's reinspection
- Step 1Read the appraisal conditionsFind the exact line the appraiser or the lender marked as a required repair, such as a roof, a basement or a crawl space finding, and the form your loan type will use to close it out.
- Step 2Prime finds the source and the extentPrime Restoration inspects the water damage with a moisture meter and a thermal camera and hands the homeowner a line-item repair scope that names the cause and every area the water damage reached.
- Step 3A licensed trade handles the roof or the pipeIf the source is the roof or a pipe, a licensed roofer or a licensed plumber repairs it; Prime can help get one out. Prime Restoration does the water damage repair itself: water removal, drying, mold from the leak, drywall, flooring, ceilings and the rebuild, under Michigan Residential Builder license #262500492.
- Step 4Document the finished repairPrime hands the homeowner dated photos, moisture readings and a completion record that match the water damage repair scope line by line.
- Step 5The lender orders the reinspectionThe homeowner gives the lender or the appraiser Prime's documentation for the Form HUD-92051 compliance inspection or the Form 1004D completion report, whichever the loan uses, and the lender clears the condition.
FHA, conventional and HECM loans: how each treats water damage
| Loan type | What it flags for water | What closes the condition |
|---|---|---|
| FHA | A roof with less than two years of life, a damp or wet basement, a crawl space with standing water or a smell of mold | Compliance Inspection Report, Form HUD-92051 |
| Conventional (Fannie Mae / Freddie Mac) | A C5 or C6 condition rating: a significantly worn roof, an active roof leak, water intrusion with structural damage, or a failing foundation | Repair to at least a C5 rating, confirmed on the Completion Report, Form 1004D |
| HECM reverse mortgage | Any property standard the house fails to meet because of water damage, including on an HECM for Purchase | Repair Set Aside funds released after inspection, or on a purchase, the seller's repair before closing |
What does Prime Restoration do for a lender-required repair?
Related pages: appraisal blocked by water damage, what appraisers look for, HELOC or refinance stopped by water damage, selling a house with water damage in Michigan and water damage restoration.
Prime Restoration finds the water source and the full extent of the water damage with a moisture meter and a thermal camera, then writes a line-item repair scope the homeowner can hand to the lender, the appraiser or a buyer. Prime does the water damage repair itself under Michigan Residential Builder license #262500492: water removal, drying, mold that came from the leak, drywall, flooring, ceilings and the rebuild. A roof or a plumbing leak needs a licensed roofer or a licensed plumber to fix the source, and Prime Restoration can help a homeowner get one out.
At the end of the repair, Prime gives the homeowner dated photos, moisture readings and a completion record built for the lender's reinspection. The homeowner hands that record to the lender or the appraiser for the reinspection.
If the water damage comes from a sudden event a homeowner's policy covers, such as a burst pipe or a water heater failure, the homeowner files the claim and Prime documents the loss and writes the repair scope. The policy and the carrier decide what the policy covers. Call Prime Restoration first at (586) 277-1069, then report the loss to the carrier the same day.
Prime Restoration is a family water damage restoration business serving Macomb and Oakland County, Michigan since 1988, and arrives in about 25 minutes across Macomb, Oakland, Washtenaw and Huron counties, including Sterling Heights, Shelby Township, Clinton Township, Rochester Hills and Troy.

